In the horse sacrifice of King Ashtaka of the Vishwamitra dynasty, many renowned kings gathered, including Ashtaka’s three brothers: Pratardana, Vasumanas, and Sivi, son of Usinara. When the sacrifice was over, Ashtaka, with his brothers, rode away in his chariot. On the way, they encountered the celestial sage Narada and invited him to join them. Narada accepted and, during their journey, one king, after honouring Narada, asked him, “O holy sage, may I ask you something?” Narada agreed, and the king inquired, “All four of us have long lives and virtues, and we have earned our place in heaven. But who among us will fall first?”
Narada replied, “This Ashtaka will descend first.” Curious, the questioner asked why. Narada explained, “I once visited Ashtaka and rode with him in his chariot outside the city. Along the way, we saw thousands of cows, each uniquely colored. When I asked Ashtaka whose cows they were, he responded, ‘I have given these away.’ He said this to praise himself. It’s for this self-praise that Ashtaka will fall.”
After hearing this, one of the brothers asked, “Of the three of us remaining, who will fall first?” Narada responded, “Pratardana.” The king asked the reason, and Narada explained, “During my time with Pratardana, he once gave away horses from his chariot to Brahmanas, who requested them. However, after giving away all his horses, he remarked, ‘There is now nothing left for the Brahmanas,’ expressing reluctance despite his generosity. For this, he will fall.”
Next, one of the two remaining kings asked, “Between Vasumanas and Sivi, who will fall?” Narada answered, “Vasumanas will fall next.” When asked for the reason, Narada recounted, “Once, during a ceremony performed by Brahmanas, a flowery car appeared. I praised it, and Vasumanas offered it to me, but only verbally. When I visited him again, he merely praised the car himself without actually gifting it to me. For withholding his offering, Vasumanas will fall.”
Narada explained why Sivi would ascend to heaven without falling. “A Brahmana once asked Sivi for food, and Sivi offered anything he wanted. The Brahmana demanded Sivi’s son, Vrihadgarbha, as food. Sivi, committed to his word, sacrificed and prepared his son as a meal for the Brahmana. However, when the Brahmana—a form of the god Vidhatri testing Sivi’s virtue—later revealed himself, Sivi’s son was miraculously restored, unharmed and radiant. Sivi explained to his counsellors that he acted not for fame or wealth but out of devotion to virtue and his commitment to the Brahmanas.”
Narada concluded, “Sivi’s selflessness and adherence to righteousness make him worthy of eternal blessings.” This tale illustrates that while generosity is praiseworthy, humility, sincerity, and unwavering commitment to righteousness without regard for reward marked true virtue.
Lessons from the story of Ashtaka and his brothers
This story offers several profound life lessons, focusing on the nature of true generosity, humility, and commitment to virtue. Here are the key lessons we can draw:
True Generosity Is Selfless and Sincere – Each king showed generosity, but only King Sivi gave without expecting praise or recognition. Sivi’s willingness to sacrifice even his son at the Brahmana’s request shows that genuine giving comes from a deep place of devotion, not from a desire for admiration.
Humility Enhances Virtue – Ashtaka’s self-praise diminished the value of his charity. This emphasizes that even the most noble acts can lose their virtue when accompanied by self-promotion. True virtue is silent and does not seek attention; it values the act itself rather than the recognition.
Faith in Righteousness Overcomes Challenges – Sivi’s unshakable commitment to fulfilling his promise, even when faced with the devastating prospect of sacrificing his son, shows that steadfastness in virtue can bring miraculous outcomes. His resolve illustrates that faith in one’s values can lead to unexpected blessings.
Words and Intentions Matter in Giving – Pratardana’s hesitation in his generosity and Vasumanas’ insincerity in offering the flowery car show that intentions and words can affect the outcome of our actions. Generosity should be wholehearted, as reluctance or detraction can reduce its worth.
Virtue Is Not Conditional – Sivi’s actions underline that the path of virtue is constant and should not depend on personal gain, reputation, or fear of loss. His actions were driven by compassion and a sense of duty rather than a desire for rewards.
Unwavering Commitment to Righteousness Is Rewarded – Sivi’s ascent to heaven without falling signifies that unwavering commitment to righteousness, even at personal cost, earns lasting respect and blessings. His actions suggest that the highest rewards come to those who uphold their values consistently, regardless of the consequences.
The story presents a hierarchy of spiritual merit:
- Lowest: Giving with self-praise (Ashtaka)
- Next: Giving with regret (Pratardana)
- Next: Making unfulfilled promises (Vasumanas)
- Highest: Giving selflessly without expectation (Sivi)
These lessons are particularly relevant today because they teach us:
- To give without seeking recognition
- To fulfil our promises
- To act with pure intention
- To maintain humility despite achievements
- To understand that motivation matters more than the act itself
- To recognize that true virtue requires complete dedication
In essence, this story teaches that true virtue lies in the purity of intentions, humility, and unwavering commitment to doing good without expecting rewards. It encourages us to give generously, act humbly, and remain steadfast in our values, even in the face of great personal challenges.
